You are currently viewing Partnership Dispute in Pakistan: How to Check Your Partner’s Accounts

Partnership Dispute in Pakistan: How to Check Your Partner’s Accounts

Most partnerships in Pakistan start on trust and a handshake. One partner brings the money, the other runs the shop, the factory or the office. For a few years it works. Then the profit share starts arriving late, the stock in the godown does not match what you were told, or your partner stops answering questions about the bank account. You are no longer sure what the business is really earning, and you do not know what you are entitled to ask for.

This guide explains, in practical terms, what the law gives you as a partner, how to check your partner’s accounts without blowing up the relationship on day one, and when an independent third-party audit is worth commissioning. It is written for sole investors, sleeping partners and working partners in small and medium firms across Pakistan.

Your Rights as a Partner Under the Partnership Act, 1932

Partnerships in Pakistan are governed by the Partnership Act, 1932. Your partnership deed can change many of the default rules, but four provisions matter most when you suspect a problem, and they cannot simply be ignored by the partner who controls the books.

RightSectionWhat it means in practice
Access to the booksSection 12(d)Every partner has a right to have access to, inspect and copy any of the books of the firm. A working partner cannot refuse a sleeping partner access to the ledgers.
True accounts and full informationSection 9Partners must be just and faithful to each other and render true accounts and full information of all things affecting the firm.
Accounting for secret profitsSection 16A partner who makes a personal profit from the firm’s business, property or name must account for it and pay it to the firm.
Dissolution by the courtSection 44Misconduct, persistent breach of the agreement, or conduct that makes it impractical to carry on the business together are grounds to ask the court to dissolve the firm.

Section 12(d) is the one most people do not know about, and the most useful. You do not need to prove fraud before you ask to see the books. The right to inspect and copy them exists simply because you are a partner.

Stopped trusting the figures your partner gives you?

We examine the books, bank statements and stock independently and give you a written report backed by evidence. Led by an Advocate High Court.

The Registration Trap: Is Your Firm Registered?

Before you think about court, check one thing: is the partnership registered with the Registrar of Firms? Many small partnerships in Pakistan run for years on an unregistered deed on stamp paper, or on no deed at all.

Section 69 of the Partnership Act places serious limits on unregistered firms. In broad terms, a partner of an unregistered firm cannot file a suit against the firm or the other partners to enforce rights arising from the partnership agreement or the Act. The Supreme Court in PLD 2016 SC 214 confirmed that this bar applies to the unregistered firm and its partners alike, so suing in your personal name does not get around it.

There is an important exception. Section 69(3) keeps open the right to sue for dissolution of the firm and for accounts of a dissolved firm. So a partner in an unregistered firm who wants the books examined by a court usually has to ask for dissolution and accounts together, not just “accounts” while the business carries on.

That is a big decision. It is one more reason to get the facts first, through your own inspection or an independent review, and decide on the legal route only once you know what the numbers show.

Warning Signs That Something Is Wrong

None of these prove dishonesty on their own. Businesses have bad months, and some partners are simply poor record-keepers. But when several appear together, it is time to look properly.

  • Sales look steady or growing, but your profit share keeps shrinking
  • You are given summaries and totals, never the ledger, the bank statements or the invoices
  • Cash sales are high and bank deposits are low
  • Stock “shortages” or “damage” are written off regularly
  • New suppliers appear that nobody else has heard of, often at higher prices
  • The business pays for personal expenses, or relatives are on the payroll
  • Income tax and sales tax returns show different figures from what you were told
  • Your partner becomes defensive or delays when you ask simple questions

How to Check Your Partner’s Accounts: Step by Step

  1. Read your partnership deed first. Check the profit-sharing ratio, who is authorised to operate the bank account, how drawings and salaries are treated, and whether there is an arbitration clause. The deed decides much of what follows.
  2. Ask in writing to inspect and copy the books. A short, polite letter or email referring to your right as a partner is enough. Keep it factual. A written request also creates a record if access is refused.
  3. Collect the documents you can get independently. As a partner you can usually obtain bank statements, FBR records such as filed income tax and sales tax returns, and supplier or customer confirmations without relying on the other partner.
  4. Reconcile the basics. Compare declared sales with bank deposits, purchases with stock movement, and the profit you were paid with the profit shown in the tax return. Most problems show up in these three comparisons.
  5. Count the stock. If the business holds inventory, a physical count reconciled to the stock records often answers the question faster than any ledger.
  6. Bring in an independent reviewer if the numbers do not add up. A third party with no stake in the dispute can test the records and report what the evidence shows, which carries far more weight than one partner’s suspicion.

What a Third-Party Audit Adds

A third-party audit in a partnership dispute is not the statutory audit of a company. It is an independent review commissioned to answer a specific question, such as “what was the true profit for the last three years?” or “does the stock in the books actually exist?”.

A good review ties every finding to its source document: the invoice, the bank entry, the stock sheet. That matters because the report may end up in a negotiation between the partners, in a bank file, before an arbitrator or in court. A report full of opinions is easy to challenge. A report built on evidence is not.

It also protects the relationship where it can be saved. Very often the review shows poor record-keeping rather than theft, and the partners agree on corrected figures, a proper bookkeeping system and a clear deed going forward.

Mistakes to Avoid

Accusing before you have evidence. Once the accusation is made, records tend to disappear and positions harden. Gather facts quietly first.

Taking matters into your own hands. Locking the shop, taking stock or withdrawing money from the firm’s account to “secure your share” can expose you to claims of your own.

Ignoring the registration question. Filing the wrong kind of suit for an unregistered firm can cost months before the case is even heard on merit.

Waiting too long. The longer a problem runs, the harder older records become to recover, and the larger the amount at stake.

Need the facts before you decide what to do?

Tell us what you need answered. We send a written scope and a fixed fee before any work starts, and we handle the matter discreetly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my partner refuse to show me the books?

Not lawfully. Under section 12(d) of the Partnership Act, 1932, every partner has a right to have access to and to inspect and copy any of the books of the firm, subject to anything your deed validly provides.

Our partnership is not registered. Can I still go to court?

Section 69 bars most suits by partners of an unregistered firm, but it keeps open a suit for dissolution of the firm and for accounts of a dissolved firm. Get legal advice on your specific facts before filing anything.

Is a third-party audit the same as a statutory audit?

No. A statutory audit of a company’s financial statements is required by the Companies Act 2017 and is signed by a chartered accountant firm. A third-party audit is an independent review commissioned for a specific purpose, such as a partnership dispute.

Will my partner know about the review?

It depends on what records are needed. Much of the early work, such as analysing bank statements and tax returns you already have access to, can be done without involving the other partner. A stock count or ledger inspection usually cannot.

Can the report be used in court or arbitration?

A report that ties each finding to its source records can support a negotiation, an arbitration or a court case. How much weight it carries is ultimately for the forum to decide.

The Bottom Line

If you have stopped trusting the numbers, you do not have to choose between silence and a lawsuit. Use your right to inspect the books, check the basics against the bank and the tax returns, and if the figures still do not add up, get an independent view backed by evidence. Then decide, with the facts in hand, whether to fix the partnership or end it properly.

Irshad and Company carries out independent reviews of partnership accounts, stock and cash for partners, investors and lenders in Lahore and across Pakistan. See our Third Party Audit service, or read about registering a partnership firm properly from the start.

This article is general information on the Partnership Act, 1932 and is not legal advice for your specific case. Partnership deeds and facts differ; take advice before starting any proceedings.

Aneel Irshad Khan

I am an Advocate of the High Court with over a decade of experience in corporate law, taxation, and financial consultancy. As a Certified Financial Consultant, Tax Consultant, Forensic Expert, and QuickBooks Expert, I specialize in tax compliance, business registration, and financial reporting, with a focus on IT exporters and freelancers. A member of the Punjab Bar Council, Lahore Bar Association, and Lahore Tax Bar Association, I provide tailored solutions to help clients navigate legal and financial complexities. I am also a Registered Income Tax Practitioner with FBR (Reg. No. 871) and have been in tax practice since 2008.

Leave a Reply